Meet Our Agents

  • Patti-Jo Toellner

    Owner/Licensed Health and Life Insurance Consultant

    Patti-Jo Toellner is the Owner, CEO of 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC. With over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, she is recognized as an expert...

    view profile
  • Staci Evans

    Licensed Health and Life Insurance Consultant

    Staci Evans is a Licensed Health & Life Insurance Consultant with expertise in interpreting the Affordable Care Act and Medicare. As an independent consultant,...

    view profile
  • Justin Zastrow

    Licensed Health Insurance Consultant

    Justin specializes in Individual, Medicare and Group products. Let him find the right plan for you.

    view profile
  • Joan Sheahan

    Property & Casualty Consultant

    Joan is the newest addition to the team at 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC. As a Property & Casualty Consultant, she brings many years of varied experience helping...

    view profile

“Just a note to let you know how pleased I am with my plan. My friend introduced me to Patti Jo from 5 Star Insurance Group. She met with us at a very convenient location and compared my existing insurance with another- “Line by Line.” I was thoroughly confident I was making the right decision to apply for this new plan. I have already experienced a significant difference in my prescription drugs and a doctors visit. Thank you! 5 Star and Patti Jo!”

Anne Koenig