With over 35 years of experience in the insurance industry, I am recognized as an expert in Individual Health and Medicare insurance sales.
Seeing a need for a different approach to Health and Life insurance in Wisconsin, I left corporate insurance and started PJ Toellner Insurance Agency in 2008 which would later become 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC. With this new independence, I was able to deliver a whole new kind of experience for my clients. An experience that is custom tailored to each individual.
Being local and independent allows my clients to receive an unbiased viewpoint and a reliable source for future concerns and questions.
In my spare time, I participate in a variety of charities including Make-a-Wish, Feeding America, American Cancer Society, and other local community charities. My husband Nick and I enjoy a variety of outdoor activities including biking, hiking, kayaking, gardening, fishing and boating. We also have a passion for travel.
In addition to Wisconsin, I am licensed to sell in Arizona, Florida, North Carolina, Michigan, Maine, and Texas.
Click the link below to get a quote or email me on how I can help you navigate the Affordable Care Act, Medicare, Dental and Life Insurance.
Senior Health Insurance Advisor
In September of 2010 I made the choice to switch from stay-at-home mom to taking an office position with 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC. Wanting to do more to help our clients, I got my Health Insurance license in July 2011 and my Life Insurance license in March 2016.
As an independent advisor, I have spent many hours studying and researching the health insurance markets, constantly sharpening my knowledge, and succeeding at the challenging task of working with a multitude of different health insurance companies. My goal is leveraging the products and expertise of these companies to educate my client so they can choose the best insurance plan to fit their individual or family needs.
I graduated from The University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh with my Bachelor of Business Administration in Finance and Economics.
When not working, I most enjoy spending time with my family. I am actively involved with my church and enjoy gardening, camping, and biking, but mostly playing with my grandson. My husband and I also have been enjoying traveling more now that the kids are older.
Click the link below to get a quote or email me on how I can help you navigate the Affordable Care Act, Medicare, and Life Insurance.
Health Insurance Advisor
In 2015 I returned to my home state of Wisconsin and joined the 5 Star Insurance Team after working for Blue Cross Blue Shield of NJ for over 15 years. I brought with me a knowledge of the ACA and Marketplace as well as a passion for providing an enriched experience to my clients.
As the leader of 5 Star Insurance Group’s marketing, I work to provide educational and entertaining newsletters, videos and commercials for our company. Finding the best ways to keep everyone informed and up to date regardless of how we connect is always a top priority. I am licensed to sell insurance plans in MN, NC and WI.
I graduated from the University of Wisconsin - Green Bay with a Bachelor's degree in English and Secondary Education in 2003. This degree helped prepare me with the ability to deliver complex information to individuals in a clearcut manner
In my free time I enjoy playing games with my family. Going out skating and biking, and taking in craft fairs and farmers markets.
Start shopping for Insurance plan Below!
Health Insurance Advisor
Prior to joining the 5 Star Insurance Group family, I worked at UnitedHealthcare for over 5 years. I began my insurance journey in Medicare Advantage/Prescription Drug Telesales and later helped pilot the Digital Sales Advisor Team where I was able to interact with and enroll clients online.
Now, I help clients navigate their Medicare or Individual health insurance options. In addition to Wisconsin, I am licensed to sell in Arizona, Florida, North Carolina, Michigan, Maine, and Texas!
I also get to utilize my Associate's Degree in Digital Media Technology to help manage our Social Media Presence. I create images and posts to educate our community and keep everyone up to date on the ever-changing world of insurance.
Outside of work you can find me spending time at home with my daughter, Hazel, and Husband, Jordan. When it’s nice out I like to spend my time like a true Wisconsinite, camping and fishing.
Contact me today so I can help you navigate through the many insurance plans available so we can find the perfect fit for you!
Associate Health Insurance Advisor
I am the Prescription Drug Advisor here at 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC. My main job responsibility is to research the best prescription drug plan for your individual drug needs while saving you money. Knowing there are many expensive medications out there, I research to find inexpensive options such as foundations, website and discount cards for expensive medications.
I started working with 5 Star Insurance Group in an Administrative role while completing my Associates Degree in Criminal Justice at Fox Valley Technical College in 2017. After graduating, I decided to stay with the 5 Star family and I acquired my WI Health Insurance License in 2018. Since then, I have been learning the various Medicare plans offered in the state of WI and I am excited to help clients find their best options!
I was the recipient of the 2021 5 Star Employee of the Year award due to my excellent customer service and strong team player skills. I am also your go to person if you are having an issue with your insurance policy as I assist with member concerns.
When I am not working, I cuddle my dogs, Pretzel and Charlie and enjoy spending time with my kids, Brooklyn and Gavin. You can find us on adventures in nature searching for reptiles, bird watching, and doing yard work.
We are more than your average Insurance Agency. When you are a client of ours, you are Family. We look out for you and always put your needs first.
We are Independent & Local, Wisconsin is our home. When you call; you reach us, not an automated message or a call center in another location. By choosing 5 Star Insurance Group, LLC, you are putting your trust in an Ethical, Local Business.
We offer Superior Service. As an Independent Agency, 5 Star Insurance Group emphasizes after-the-sale customer service, including personalized claim assistance and routine reviews of each customer’s ever changing insurance needs.
5 Star Insurance Group, LLC values your education above all else. We are lucky to have the opportunity to work with WBAY Channel 2 and deliver regular content about the latest topics in Insurance. Be sure to check out our videos on our YouTube page or Directly on Channel 2!
We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.
5 Star Insurance Group, LLC 119 N. McCarthy Rd Suite G Appleton, WI 54913 US
08:00 am – 05:00 pm
Evening and Weekend appointments are available upon request.